Project case study · Hendersonville, TN 37075
Malarkey Highlander Roof Replacement in Hendersonville
Antique Brown shingles. Corrected ventilation. Connected roof drainage. This project paired a complete roof replacement with four 14-inch turbine vents, Bulldog gutter screens, and downspout extensions, backed by a five-year workmanship warranty.
See the project
The inspection, installation & follow-up
Quick Answer
What did this Hendersonville roof replacement include?
Mr. GoodRoof replaced the roof on this Hendersonville, Tennessee 37075 home with Malarkey Highlander NEX AR shingles in Antique Brown. The scope also included four 14-inch turbine vents, replacement pipe boots, Bulldog gutter screens, and extensions routing the second-story downspouts to the first-story gutters. This project carries a five-year workmanship warranty. The technician’s walkthrough explains why the work went beyond the visible shingles.
Start with the condition of the roof
New shingles were only part of the answer.
In the technician’s inspection narrative, the existing roof was approximately 18 years old. He described deteriorated pipe boots, shingles lifting and coming unsealed in a pattern he called “zippering,” and areas of rotted roof decking visible from the attic.
Storm damage was not identified as the problem in that assessment. The findings called for more than replacing the roof covering: the ventilation and vulnerable roof penetrations also needed attention.
Age was context, not the diagnosis. The scope followed the conditions found on this house. A different 18-year-old roof may still be repairable.
Compare roof repair and roof replacement, or see the full Mr. GoodRoof roof replacement approach.
Material & color selection
Highlander NEX AR in Antique Brown
The homeowner’s selected shingle for this project was Malarkey Highlander NEX AR in Antique Brown. The warm brown blend complements the brick and white trim. These photos offer a useful starting point for comparing the look; view a physical sample before choosing a color for your own home.
Malarkey identifies Highlander AR as an architectural shingle made with NEX® polymer-modified rubberized asphalt and a UL 2218 Class 3 impact rating. Its granules include algae-resistant and smog-reducing features.[1]
Class 3 describes laboratory-tested impact resistance, not a hail-proof roof. The product rating and the warranty for an individual installation are separate considerations.
Explore Malarkey shingle options and color selection.
Project photos show the actual setting and installed color. Lighting, screen settings, and manufacturing variation can affect color appearance.
The work beneath the appearance
Four 14-inch turbine vents, specified for this roof
The ventilation correction included four 14-inch turbine vents distributed across the roof. These roof-mounted exhaust vents are often called whirlybirds. Their role is different from the shingles: they provide an exhaust path for the attic.
The technician measured the attic and compared the existing box vents with the calculated need for that particular style of vent. His reported counts were:
| Attic section | Existing box vents | Calculated need, same vent style |
|---|---|---|
| Larger section | 5 | 12 |
| Smaller section | 2 | 4 |
These are project-specific calculations for the original box-vent style. They are not a count recommendation for your home or a stated box-vent-to-turbine conversion.
Exhaust is only one side of ventilation
The plan also has to account for intake, attic layout, and each product’s available airflow area. Lomanco’s guidance explains why vent quantities depend on attic size and Net Free Area, and why intake must be coordinated with exhaust.[2][3]
Four turbines are not automatically “proper ventilation” for every roof. A count of visible vents does not establish that the whole system is balanced.
Follow-up observation: The technician reported an attic reading around 96–97°F during the follow-up visit. That is a single observation from this visit, not a before-and-after temperature comparison, an energy-savings result, or a target for every attic.
Does your roof replacement estimate address ventilation?
Ask what the attic needs before choosing a vent. We can review roof condition and ventilation as part of your evaluation.
Protecting the roof edge
Bulldog gutter screens and a connected route to the lower gutters
New gutter screens
Bulldog gutter screens were installed along the gutter runs, with screw fastening described in the technician’s walkthrough. The photographs show the fitted screens and brown shingles together at the roof edge.
The gutter work focused on the screens and downspout routing. Those details help explain why a roof replacement estimate should account for drainage, not just shingles.
Second-story downspout extensions
The scope also included extending all second-story downspouts from the upper roof down to the first-story gutters, creating a defined route between the gutter levels rather than ending the upper discharge on the lower roof surface.
The downspout route, lower gutter condition, outlets, and screen fit belong in the same conversation. Choosing shingles does not resolve those details by itself.
for this project
Know what backs the work
A five-year workmanship warranty
This Hendersonville project includes a five-year Mr. GoodRoof workmanship warranty. The written project agreement governs the scope of coverage, exclusions, and claim requirements.
Workmanship coverage and manufacturer product warranties are separate. Reviewing both in writing helps you understand what is covered, who backs it, and how to request help if a concern arises.
When comparing your own proposals, ask for the workmanship term and product warranty in writing, along with the roofing-system components included in the estimate.
From the technician’s walkthrough
Project video summary
Read the inspection and installation summary
The technician began with the pipe boots and found deteriorated seals. He then inspected the roof slopes and described lifting, unsealed shingles rather than storm damage as the concern. The attic inspection revealed deteriorated decking and ventilation shortfalls.
The work included a complete roof replacement with Malarkey Highlander NEX AR shingles. For this Hendersonville project, the selected color was Antique Brown. The ventilation specification called for four 14-inch turbine vents, and the scope also included replacement pipe boots, Bulldog gutter screens, and upper downspout extensions to the lower gutters.
The follow-up walkthrough checked the roof details, pipe boots, and screens and reported an attic reading around 96–97°F. The broader lesson is to evaluate the whole roofing system rather than treating new shingles as the complete solution.
Edited summary of the supplied technician narrative and project scope, not a verbatim caption transcript.
Questions about this project
Hendersonville roof replacement FAQs
What shingle and color were used on this Hendersonville home?
The roof was replaced with Malarkey Highlander NEX AR architectural shingles in Antique Brown. The project photographs show the brown shingle blend beside the home’s brick exterior. Color appearance varies with lighting and screen settings; compare physical samples when choosing your own roof.
Are the Highlander shingles on this project Class 4?
No. Malarkey lists Highlander AR as a UL 2218 Class 3 impact-rated shingle. A laboratory impact rating is not a guarantee against hail damage. Do not confuse Highlander AR with Malarkey’s Class 4 shingle options.[1]
Does every roof need four 14-inch turbine vents?
No. Four 14-inch turbines were specified for this project. Vent type, quantity, and placement should be selected for the attic layout, available intake, and product ventilation capacity. The same count is not a prescription for a different home.
Were gutters replaced, or were gutter screens added?
This scope included new Bulldog gutter screens and extensions connecting second-story downspouts to first-story gutters. It does not describe a complete replacement of every gutter. Gutter screens and downspout routing serve different parts of the drainage system.
What workmanship warranty backs this roof replacement?
This project includes a five-year Mr. GoodRoof workmanship warranty, subject to its written terms. Manufacturer product coverage is separate. Ask which workmanship and product warranties apply to your own estimate rather than assuming all roofing projects receive the same coverage.
Can I have my roof inspected before deciding on replacement?
Yes. Start with an inspection and a clear explanation of the findings. A localized issue on a serviceable roof may call for repair; broader deterioration may warrant replacement. The recommendation should follow your roof’s condition, not the scope of someone else’s project.
Planning your own Hendersonville roof project?
See what your roof needs before choosing the shingles.
Get a written roof replacement estimate that explains the proposed materials, ventilation, roof-edge work, and workmanship coverage. If a repair is the more appropriate next step, we’ll explain that option.
Free inspection and estimate requests are subject to service availability, scheduling, and safe roof and attic access. Submitting a request does not confirm an appointment.
Continue your roof planning
Related Hendersonville and roofing resources
- Roof replacement in Hendersonville
- Hendersonville roofing services
- Roof and attic ventilation
- Malarkey shingle options
- Roof repair options
- Complete roofing service range
Product and ventilation references
- Malarkey: Highlander AR product specifications. Product specifications are separate from the warranty issued for an individual installation.
- Lomanco: How many attic vents are needed?
- Lomanco: Coordinating intake, exhaust, and attic airflow.
Project information and photographs: Mr. GoodRoof. Hendersonville, TN 37075.
